Paul Reynolds, world affairs correspondent for BBC Online, says that the decisions of diplomacy to conclude the Gaza war will have to wait for Israel's decision of arms.
This conclusion is inevitable in the face of a determination by the Israeli government that it faces an unacceptable threat from Gaza that must be dealt with.In February 2003, I published an essay at my old One Hand Clapping blog anticipating the coming Iraq campaign, entitled, "The coming American Holy War." This was not in invest the Iraq war with sacredness by any means, but to describe modern American war-making as drawing on both the Northern and Southern models of American history.
By delaying ground operations for a week, it gave Hamas a chance to back down and call a halt to the firing of rockets into Israel. But Hamas chose confrontation, probably fearing that to do otherwise would be to show weakness. ...
Much depends on whether Hamas has been able to recover from the shock it must have received eight days ago when the air assault began.
On the other hand, a decisive Israeli ground intervention could leave the door open to negotiation - but only if Hamas chooses to walk through that door.
Lincoln did not become an abolitionist until he understood that the the North would never suffer the abattoir of the Civil War merely to preserve the Union, but it would bleed profusely "to make men free," as Julia Ward Howe's hymn urged. In [the Civil War movie] Gods and Generals there is a scene where Union Col. Joshua Chamberlain (Jeff Daniels) tells his brother, also a Union officer, that if they both have to die to free the slaves, then so be it, even though abolition was not an original aim of the war.I think that is what the Israelis have concluded in in deciding to make war against Hamas. I explained earlier that Israel is not making mere gestures of offering symbols with its air and ground campaign, but is engaging in intentional lethality to inflict great harm upon Hamas. This is violence with a purpose, though, which correspondent Reynolds recognizes.
It is the Northerners kind of war that Americans have waged more utterly than any other. As military historian T. R. Fehrenbach wrote in This Kind of War, "Wars fought for a higher purpose must always be the most hideous of all." War is such an awful thing that it must be entered into for only the most transcendental purposes. Hence, any war - as opposed to a punitive expedition, such as Panama, 1989 - that Americans engage in must be a crusade, because only crusades can justify the costs and the suffering. War is to be waged only reluctantly, even sadly, but when waged, done so ferociously.
Clausewitz wrote that war is a continuation of politics by forceful means. In fact, if the resort to the sword comes, it must serve only political purposes, else it mindless, pointless destruction. In my 2003 essay, I continued,
In American Holy War, the political end is secondary to the military victory. Political structures are imposed by Holy War's victorious conclusion, they do not determine the conclusion. The role of politics is to pick up the pieces when total victory has been won.I would note, though, that total victory or unconditional surrender has not been an American war objective since 1945. As for Israel, its government and people alike seem to have reached a Wilsonian point: the future political structures about its security to the south shall be are imposed by Operation Cast Lead's military conclusion, not the other way round. Political processes will not determine the conclusion (except, of course, the internal politics of the Olmert government and Israel generally).
This is also the Wilsonian way of war, although Woodrow Wilson neither originated it nor saw its apotheosis. It was left to Franklin Roosevelt to do that. Wilson gave it its most eloquent sound bite: "Make the world safe for democracy." Wilsonianism's adherents see national security as dependent upon international frameworks: treaties, concordances, assemblies and the like. This is a fine ideal, but all international frameworks break down eventually. When they do, the Jacksonians of America have their day (named after Andrew Jackson, not Stonewall Jackson).
OTOH, Israeli columnist Larry Derfner of the JPost says that the Gaza war was unjust for Israel to begin, though with the right politcal settlement after the military operation, justice may yet be retrived from the war. When Israel withdrew from Gaza in 2005, "Right away, we blockaded Gaza's coast. We blockaded Gaza's airspace. We choked off the delivery of supplies to Gaza by land. We never ended the occupation - we just do it now by remote control."
And if the argument is made that we had to bang the [snip] out of Hamas to teach it a lesson, and only now can we lift the siege and expect it to abide by a cease-fire - then I accept. Then I was wrong to oppose Operation Cast Lead, because that was the stick Israel had to apply in order to get Hamas to take the carrot.This is the key issue: the responsibility of Israel's military is to establish and enforce a reality on the ground in Gaza that enables Israel's civilian leaders to bring about an enduring political settlement from a position of authority and that displaces Hamas as an equal at the table. One hopes that Olmert et. al. actually did envision the kind of political settlement they want - Derfner's outline seems reasonable to me - but the PM's track record is not very encouraging on that score.
But if we're just going to keep banging away until, as some Israelis seem to envision, the Palestinians fall on their knees and say, "Okay, we surrender. You were right all along, we won't touch you anymore, we don't need an airport, we don't need a seaport, we would just like a little more humanitarian aid and we'll be eternally grateful" - then forget it. Then Operation Cast Lead is utterly reckless, futile and immoral. Then we're leaving the Palestinians with nothing to lose, and we're fighting a war that has no logical end, a war that could expand in all sorts of directions.
Also, there seems to be a widespread view among Israelis that Olmert and Foreign Minister Livni reached an accord with Palestinian Authority President Mahmud Abbas to take out Hamas so that the PA can reassert control over Gaza, presumably not because the PA wants Israel to disappear any less than Hamas, but because they are more amenable to international influence. I guess. Last week, Israel killed Nizar Rayyan, Hamas' military commander, who was "a sworn enemy not only of Israel, but also of the Palestinian Authority and its president, Mahmoud Abbas," reports Arab reporter Khaled Abu Toameh. Rayyan "led the Hamas militiamen who defeated Abbas's security forces in the Gaza Strip in the summer of 2007. ... A Hamas spokesman said he did not rule out the possibility that the PA had asked Israel to kill Rayyan because of his role in the Hamas-Fatah clashes in 2007."
2 comments:
The Thunder Run has linked to this post in the - Web Reconnaissance for 01/05/2009 A short recon of what’s out there that might draw your attention, updated throughout the day...so check back often.
Thanks for the link! The correct address to your post is:
http://thunderrun.blogspot.com/2009/01/web-reconnaissance-for-01052009.html
Post a Comment