Thursday, March 5, 2009

"... the most authoritarian government in centuries"

By Donald Sensing

Those are the words of Brit blogger Cranmer referring to the UK government headed by the same man who addressed the US Congress yesterday. It would be the guy pictured at right, Prime Minister Gordon Brown.


What is it about Brown's government that aroused such calumny? A suspicion that Brown expects civil unrest in Britain (it has already occurred across much of Europe) is is preparing to use the British army to quell it. 
Why otherwise are Army personnel being asked if they would be prepared to 'open fire' on UK citizens during civil disturbances?

Why otherwise are ‘special briefing sessions’ being held to ascertain whether or not members of Her Majesty’s Armed Forces would fire on their own nationals?
Yes, it smells of conspiracy theory. But remember that Constitutional protections as known in the United States are not known in Britain, even though we and they enjoy many of the same rights. However, there is a crucial distinction. In the US we believe in the divine right of rights themselves, whilst Britain's heritage is rooted in the divine right of kings (or queens). Hence,
‘New Labour’ continues to be the most authoritarian government in centuries: it rules with all the infallible arrogance of divine right. Ancient rights have been transgressed, traditions set aside and liberties curtailed. The Civil Contingencies Act 2004 is nothing but an ‘Enabling Act’ which gives the government the authority to declare a state of emergency – with no possibility of objective scrutiny or challenge – and thereafter rule by decree. The ‘emergency’ can be declared if there has been an incident, if an incident is occurring, or if an incident is about to occur. ...

On declaring an emergency, ministers acquire the power to make arbitrary regulations for many purposes, including ‘protecting or restoring the activities of banks or other financial institutions’ (that was prophetic) and ‘protecting or restoring activities of Parliament’. Since these regulations bypass Parliament under the Royal Prerogative, the Prime Minister has acquired absolute power to inter alia ‘give directions or orders’, ‘provide for or enable the requisition or confiscation of property’, ‘provide for or enable the destruction of property’, ‘prohibit, or enable the prohibition of, movement to or from a specified place’; and ‘prohibit, or enable the prohibition of, assemblies of specified kinds, at specified places or at specified times’.
Remember that the British prime minister is selected by Parliament but serves at the pleasure of the monarch. The PM is in fact the monarch's, not the Parliament's, minister and essentially works for her. This does not mean that the orders for a clampdown need to originate from QE2, it does mean that never in British history have the government's ministers and executors understood the people to be sovereign. They are not, not in the UK. The monarch is sovereign and by extension her government generally. The people are known as subjects, not citizens, and are ruled, not governed. 

Some definitions may help readers on the western side of the Big Pond:
The Royal Prerogative is a body of customary authority, privilege, and immunity, recognised in common law and, sometimes, in civil law jurisdictions possessing a monarchy as belonging to the Sovereign [monarch] alone. ... There may be situations in which the monarch could choose to exercise the Royal Prerogative without the advice of the Prime Minister and the Cabinet. Such situations are rare, and generally only occur in emergencies or where existing precedent does not adequately apply to the circumstances in question. [Wikipedia]
One of the powers under the Royal Prerogative is the power to declare emergencies. As for a Constitution of the UK, the term there is used not to refer to a single, definitive document such as the US Constitution, but to a large set of Parliamentary acts, court decisions and treaty obligations, and other documents and practices, that are considered to form the supreme law of the land. In theory and in practice, the Parliament enjoys supreme legal authority and so may amend the UK Constitution as it wishes (including some particulars of the Royal Prerogative) since the Constitution consists mainly of Parliamentary acts.

Now, the legal processes that Cranmer casts a suspicious eye on may in fact be simple housekeeping matters to tidy up some loose ends in the Royal Prerogative and Parliamentary acts, but he's the man on the spot, not I.

No comments: