Thursday, September 10, 2009

Well, now we know: health care is not a right, it's a coerced requirement

By Donald Sensing

I asked in an earlier post whether, if health care was a human right, we would have the right not to exercise that right: "If health care is a right, will persons have a right not to receive it?"

In other words, knowing that today several million of the uninsured people could easily afford health-care insurance but decline to buy it, will they be allowed under Obamacare to decline it?

And the president answered that question explicitly tonight: No.

Now, even if we provide these affordable options, there may be those — particularly the young and healthy — who still want to take the risk and go without coverage. ... That's why under my plan, individuals will be required to carry basic health insurance — just as most states require you to carry auto insurance.
So health care has quickly morphed from being a human right to a coerced requirement. Now to be fair to the president, I have not heard him personally claim that health care is a human right, but plenty in his party have. They have a curious view of what constitutes a right - we have to buy insurance that they approve (self insurance will cease to exist) or be punished by fines.

However, no state in the union requires auto insurance remotely like you want to require health insurance. I have known literally hundreds of fully-employed adults who quite legally did not carry auto insurance. Why? They did not own an auto. The state's requirement to purchase auto insurance is conditional on the prior, free decision made by the individual to buy or lease a car.

Our big cities are full of people who live quite well for years without ever buying auto insurance. They hail cabs and use buses and subways and els, but no car and no car insurance. And the government does not care. Its their decision.

John Hinderaker at Power Line points out another point of departure:
Traditionally, it was liability insurance that drivers were required to carry, not to protect themselves, but to protect others from their possible negligence. It is only because of no-fault laws that most states now require drivers to carry insurance that includes first-party coverage. There are some similarities, but many differences, between automobile and health insurance.