Friday, September 4, 2009

Why the president's slide?

By Donald Sensing

As President Obama prepared to address a joint session of Congress on the issue of health care, pundits on both sides of the aisle are wondering, "What happened?"

What happened to Obama's seeming invincibility and political deftness, that is.

Charles Krauthammer has some thoughts. The president, says Charles, deeply mis-read his election as a mandate.

He assumed it was personal. This, after winning by a mere seven points in a year of true economic catastrophe, of an extraordinarily unpopular Republican incumbent, and of a politically weak and unsteady opponent. Nonetheless, Obama imagined that, as Fouad Ajami so brilliantly observed, he had won the kind of banana-republic plebiscite that grants caudillo-like authority to remake everything in one's own image.
Actually, I think that Charles is off base here. I think that the fact that Obama won only 53 percent of the votes indicates that his mandate was in fact a personal one, not political.

Consider: the president's "strongly approve" rating is double-digit lower than his "strongly disapprove" rating. No one expected his sky-high rating at the beginning of the year to last, but this is a precipitous slide.


Yet the warning signs were there early. Back in March, MSNBC observed, "... there's a sizable gap between the president's personal popularity and the popularity of his policies." Sixty-eight percent of respondents had "a favorable opinion of the president," but only 54 percent (statistically unchanged since the election) were "confident that Obama has the right goals and policies for the country."

My assessment: Barack Obama was elected less on the strength of his policy proposals than on the strength of his personal appeal. That is, Americans loved him as a candidate but were only little more than bare majority in approval of his policies. His winning margin was due much more to "personal" voters than "policy" voters.

But once Jan. 21 dawns, presidents have to perform, not merely appeal. This there is broad consensus around the political spectrum, including Democrats in Congress, that Obama has not done so.

Why the slide? Fundamentally because a large number of people who loved Obama the candidate have never been very comfortable with Obama the president. And his lackluster performance so far has reinforced that discomfort.

Update: Peggy Noonan has some relevant observations.