Wednesday, November 25, 2009

Water boarding climate data

By Donald Sensing

Did climate scientists manipulate climate data to achieve a pre-determined result? Do polar bears do it on ice floes?

The texts of email messages among researchers revealed by the release of 60-plus megs of information on the servers of the East Anglia Climate Research Unit are condemning enough, but the real nails in the coffin are the programming and database files. These have drawn the scrutiny of computer programmers and computer scientists. And their analyses, new as it is, already shows that climate raw data were not merely massaged, in the words of computer scientist Charlie Martin, climate scientists were "practically water-boarding the data" to get it to support the desired conclusions. The link is to page 2 of Charlie's piece, in which he concludes that the programming was "such a mess that they can’t replicate their own results."

But put this in the context of what else we know from the CRU data dump:

1. They didn’t want to release their data or code, and they particularly weren’t interested in releasing any intermediate steps that would help someone else

2. They clearly have some history of massaging the data — practically water-boarding the data — to get it to fit their other results. Results they can no longer even replicate on their own systems.

3. They had successfully managed to restrict peer review to what we might call the “RealClimate clique” — the small group of true believers they knew could be trusted to say the right things.

As a result, it looks like they found themselves trapped. They had the big research organizations, the big grants — and when they found themselves challenged, they discovered they’d built their conclusions on fine beach sand.
I am no programmer; I took a single FORTRAN college course back in 1976 and my Army computer training was for extremely specialized targeting systems. So it's impossible for me to evaluate the coding of the CRU data.

But others can:
From the CRU code file osborn-tree6/briffa_sep98_d.pro , used to prepare a graph purported to be of Northern Hemisphere temperatures and reconstructions.
;
; Apply a VERY ARTIFICAL correction for decline!!
;
yrloc=[1400,findgen(19)*5.+1904]
valadj=[0.,0.,0.,0.,0.,-0.1,-0.25,-0.3,0.,- 0.1,0.3,0.8,1.2,1.7,2.5,2.6,2.6,$
2.6,2.6,2.6]*0.75 ; fudge factor
if n_elements(yrloc) ne n_elements(valadj) then message,’Oooops!’
;
yearlyadj=interpol(valadj,yrloc,timey)
This, people, is blatant data-cooking, with no pretense otherwise. It flattens a period of warm temperatures in the 1940s -- see those negative coefficients? Then, later on, it applies a positive multiplier so you get a nice dramatic hockey stick at the end of the century.
More detail here. The "hockey stick," long discredited, was a diagram that purported to show dramatic, rapid of global temperatures in the last 30 years from historic "norms." But it was entirely bogus.

David Warren hits the nail on the head. There is, he says, a "disheartening reality."
For, as we glean from the hacked documents, supporters of the hypothesis have been able to reverse the onus of proof. In the last resort, their argument comes down to: We say the planet is warming. And anyone who says the contrary must "prove the negative" beyond the faintest shadow of a doubt. And we will be their judges.