Thursday, August 12, 2010

Anchor babies on the increase

By Donald Sensing

USA Today:

The total number of children in the USA born to illegal immigrants on U.S. soil jumped to 4 million in 2009, up from 2.7 million in 2003, a report released Wednesday estimates.
Those children — who are automatically granted U.S. citizenship — represent 5.4% of all children under the age of 18 in the U.S. That compares to 3.7% six years earlier, according to data from the non-partisan Pew Hispanic Center. That percentage will continue rising, as an estimated 340,000 of the 4.3 million babies born in the U.S. in 2008 alone — about 8% — came from illegal immigrant parents, the report says.

The study comes as some legislators, including Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., are calling for a revision of the 14th Amendment that grants citizenship to anyone born in the United States.
The body of the Constitution does not say that anyone born inside the borders of the US is automatically a citizen. "Birthright" citizenship comes from the 14th Amendment, ratified in 1868 with the aim of ensuring that freed slaves and their children would not be denied rights of citizenship:
All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.
The phenomenon of "anchor babies" come not from the 14th Amendment but from 1965's Immigration and Naturalization Act. The reason, according to NPR, was because,
The central purpose of the new immigration law was to reunite families.
Until President Johnson signed the act into law, immigrant visas were governed by the Immigration Act of 1924. By the early 1960s, this act was seen to have its own set of problems which are not terribly relevant to this discussion, but for which there was broad agreement on the need to address.

As is almost always the case with legislation, the 1965 act's crafters and supporters - and even LBJ himself - did not foresee the enormous demographic shift in America that the law would bring about.
It leveled the immigration playing field, giving a nearly equal shot to newcomers from every corner of the world. The ceremony was held at the foot of the symbolically powerful Statue of Liberty. Yet President Johnson tried to downplay the law's significance.

"This bill that we will sign today is not a revolutionary bill. It does not affect the lives of millions," Johnson said at the signing ceremony. "It will not reshape the structure of our daily lives or add importantly to either our wealth or our power." ...

[I]n debating an overhaul of immigration policy in the 1960s, many in Congress had argued that little would change because the measure gave preference to relatives of immigrants already in America. Another provision gave preference to professionals with skills in short supply in the United States.
No one foresaw that within 30 years, Europe would become the junior supplier of professional-class immigrant applicants to America, as professional classes emerged strongly in India, across Asia and even in China.

But the main thing was the family-reunification provision. Only a year after the act was signed, the immigration service published an internal-use booklet prescient in its forecast:
It explains how each provision in the new law would lead to a rapid increase in applications and a big jump in workload — more and more so as word trickled out to those newly eligible to come. [Historian Marian] Smith says a lifetime of immigration backlogs had built up among America's foreign-born minorities. These immigrants would petition for relatives to come to the United States, and those relatives in turn would petition for other family members.
The result? Since 1965, and accelerating since the mid-1980s, the demography of the United States has changed in ways that the 1965 act's sponsors would have thought impossible at the time. And the Congress of the United States has simply lost - or acceded - control the the nation's immigration policy to other countries, especially Mexico, or to immigrants themselves. NPR explains:
[T]he chief driver of this change remains the system of family-based immigration put in place in 1965. Over time, in a process critics call "chain migration," entire families have re-established themselves in the United States. Historian Otis Graham thinks the policy has been a terrible mistake.

"Family reunification puts the decision of who comes to America in the hands of foreigners," Graham says. "Those decisions are out of the hand of the Congress — they just set up a formula and its kinship. Frankly, it could be called nepotism."
The Republicans are right: it is time for the Congress to reassert its authority over immigration into this country. It's time to end anchor babies opening the door to dozens of relatives automatically qualifying for immigration rights. The best place to begin is with defining which births invoke automatic citizenship and which do not. This will not necessarily require a Constitutional amendment, since the 14th Amendment concludes, "The Congress shall have power to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the provisions of this article."

But whether by amendment or legislation, I commend again to your attention my own "fix" on what an amendment or act should say: "14th Amendment and "birthright citizenship".