Wednesday, July 3, 2013

Are we first in the universe?

By Donald Sensing

The SETI project (Search for Extraterrestial Intelligence) is coming up empty and starting, perhaps, to ponder a shocking possibility - that homo sapiens is one of the first, maybe even the only, spacefaring life form to have developed in the galaxy.

Science writer Mark Thompson explains that even a 14-billion-year-old universe may not be old enough to result in planets teeming with life, especially intelligent life.

It seems that the evolution of stars precluded the formation of rocky planets much before the appearance of Population I stars. If that is the case, and adding a generous margin for error, it looks like the first planets like Earth would have formed no earlier than 8 billion years ago. 
If that is true, then it may well be that we are not necessarily the first life, but perhaps amongst the first intelligent life (as we know it) to evolve.
Furthermore, there is no teleology in evolution theory. No outcome is inevitable, there is no such thing as  "higher" life forms. There is only survival, or not. Hence, technological, inventive beings are not a rational development of evolution at all. There is no "rational" development of life in the first place.

And as Harvard biologist Ernst Mayr has pointed out, since life first appeared on Earth, there have been an estimated 50 billion species. And yet only one, us, has developed high intelligence. Mayr says that such intelligence does not obviously offer a species survival advantage and hence may be so rare that homo sapiens may be a "one off" in the universe.

In 2011 I put together a slide presentation for the topic to discuss Fermi's Paradox at my church. You will probably be surprised at the conclusion. Here tis:

  Bookmark and Share